Giant divorce claim could be Australia’s costliest split – but it can’t match these billionaire bust-ups

16 March 2011 By

Could this be Australia’s biggest ever divorce claim? An Adelaide woman has lodged a divorce claim worth well over $25 million against her ex-husband in what has become one of the most bitter marriage splits in history.

According to a report in The Australian, the woman, who cannot be named for legal reasons, applied to the Family Court for a $278,000 monthly support payment for herself and her only son.

While the Court rejected this claim, she is pushing ahead for a final settlement from the divorce that would see her receive more than $24 million in property (including a Swiss chalet) and other payments. Her former husband is contesting.

The bitter legal battle – the paper says the pair has been to court on 28 separate occasions – would have to be one of Australia’s biggest divorce cases.

However, even if the woman manages to win a big payout in the final settlement, she is unlikely to match Australia’s two members of the BRW Rich 200 list who have earned a big part of their fortunes from divorce settlements: Nicole Kidman and Lynette Harvey.

Kidman, valued on this year’s list with a fortune of $329 million, received a divorce settlement worth a reported $109 million when she split from actor Tom Cruise in 2001.

Lynette Harvey, the former wife of retail king Gerry Harvey, retained a large stake in Harvey Norman when the couple split in 1982. She was listed on this year’s Rich 200 with a fortune of $205 million; her stake in Harvey Norman is worth more than $170 million.

But these splits are dwarfed by what is widely seen as the biggest divorce settlement in history, finalised earlier this year – the split between US casino mogul Steve Wynn and his wife Elaine.

The pair, who have actually divorced twice (they first married in 1963, broke up in 1986 and then remarried five years later), finalised their latest settlement in January.

According to Forbes, Elaine ended up with 11,076,708 shares in Wynn Resorts as part of the settlement; based on the company’s share price, that stake is worth just over $1.06 billion.

Another billionaire bust-up that is in the process of being settled is the split between Formula One supremo Bernie Ecclestone and his ex-wife Slavica. An official cost to the split has yet to be determined, but initial estimates said the settlement could be as high as $1.7 billion.

Prior to the Wynn’s divorce settlement, the biggest divorce on record was paid by US mobile phone industry pioneer Craig McCaw, who sold a group of mobile phone assets to AT&T in 1994 for $US11.5 billion. Less than a year later, Craig and his wife Wendy split.

In the bitter divorce battle that followed, everyone from Craig’s elderly mother to Bill Gates was called to give evidence. Eventually, Wendy walked away with $US460 million in shares in telco Nextel. Unfortunately for her, those shares later tanked during the tech wreck of 2001.

(Source:  James Thomson, Smart Company, 11/06/10)

About Rushmore Forensic

Rushmore Forensic is a forensic accounting firm based in Sydney. We specialise in the investigation, and valuation of businesses subject to family law/divorce disputes.

Filed Under: Expert witness, Family law Tagged With: , ,

Assets in Divorce

13 March 2011 By

If you are in the process of divorce or leading up to divorce it’s important to understand what assets are likely to be included or excluded from the eventual property settlement. Understanding how the process works, planning for a property settlement and engaging an expert valuer/forensic accountant can all have a major impact on your financial position at the conclusion of the divorce proceedings.

For many people their assets will include some or all of the following:

  • The family home.
  • Other investment properties.
  • Household possessions.
  • Vehicles including motor bikes.
  • Boats and jet skis.
  • Investments i.e. shares and managed funds; and
  • Superannuation.

However one common asset that is often forgotten when thought turns to assets in divorce is either your or your ex’s business. Businesses come in many forms and can include small ventures such as online businesses, lawn mowing, milk delivery runs and other activities that are run for commercial gain. If you or your ex-partner is a tradesman, then there is likely to be a business and this will need to be valued as part of the property settlement.

When it comes time for a business valuation expert to value the business, then the financial records that are kept are vital pieces of potential evidence in the divorce proceedings. Many smaller businesses have poor record keeping practices and many jobs may not be formally entered into an accounting system. If you or your former partner runs a business, then it’s important to try and secure as much evidence as possible as to the true trading activity of the business. This can include obtaining copies of diaries, bank statements, MYOB or other accounting files, hard copy versions of invoices and any other documentation which shows the true financial position of the business. The value of a business can have a substantial effect on the assets in divorce, and in many situations it can exceed the value of the other assets combined.

The value of a business in a divorce can have a substantial effect on the final property settlement. The valuations can often be complex and require many subjective matters to be taken into account. An expert valuer and forensic accountant will transform various pieces of evidence (such as diaries and other financial records) into a report which clearly spells out the trading activities of the business, its financial performance and ultimately what the business is worth. The reconstruction of financial records is a core skill to a forensic accountant and together with your legal counsel will play an important role in preparing for the divorce proceedings.

About the Author

Andrew Firth is a forensic accountant based in Sydney. He is an expert valuer and specialises in reconstructing financial records and valuing businesses in litigation. If you have a divorce, commerial dispute or other forensic enquiry, Andrew would be happy to discuss this with you.

Rushmore Forensic have offices in North Sydney and Baulkham Hills. They regularly conduct forensic accounting and valuation work across Australia and internationally.

Filed Under: Expert witness, Family law Tagged With: , , ,